Melvor Idle 2 Early Skill Priority Tier List
What to train first in Melvor Idle 2 Early Access.
Tier list rules
This Melvor Idle 2 tier list ranks early and mid Early Access priority for a new or returning account. S-tier skills unlock or multiply the rest of the game. D-tier skills still matter later; they simply wait until food, Mastery, and quests are stable.
Always override the list when a quest hard-requires a skill. Pair rankings with Getting Started and Progression.
S tier — train these early and often
- Cooking — Auto Eat food is non-negotiable for combat and bosses.
- Herblore — potions multiply gathering, artisan, and combat efficiency.
- Astrology — permanent account-wide bonuses and special unlocks.
- Mastery Guild progress on your mains — not a skill, but S-tier behaviour; see Mastery Guilds.
A tier — core ladder skills
- Woodcutting — classic opener, logs, and early unlocks.
- Mining — ores for Smithing and Runecrafting pressure.
- Smithing — gear and metal progression.
- Agility — content unlocks and non-combat utility gear.
- Defence — silent combat level and survivability for every style.
B tier — strong when needed
- Fishing — food variety and materials.
- Runecrafting — required for meaningful Magic.
- Crafting / Fletching — ammo and gear components.
- Thieving — GP and loot when shop upgrades stall.
- Attack / Strength / Hitpoints — raise with combat once food is ready.
- Farming / Hunting / Ranching loops — keep artisan inputs flowing.
C tier — situational
- Firemaking — useful sink and bonuses, rarely the long-term focus.
- Prayer — powerful when points and bones are planned; weak if ignored logistically.
- Ranged / Magic — essential for triangle coverage, but gated by ammo/runes.
- Slayer — excellent mid-game direction once Auto Eat and gear exist.
D tier — park until later
- Hyper-specific endgame actions that need high levels you do not have yet
- Vanity pet chasing before food and Mastery basics
- Spending all idle time on a single maxed demo skill while new EA skills sit at 1
Example first-week priority path
- Woodcutting → Cooking food → Auto Eat online
- Mining/Smithing for Stone-to-better gear
- Clear early quests and easy Mastery tasks
- Unlock and push Astrology/Herblore/Agility
- Stabilise Defence and one full combat style
- Add money loops from Progression
Why money skills are not automatically S tier
GP matters, but GP without multipliers just buys slightly better mistakes. Early Access also buffed some early money skills after demo feedback, so check live GP/hr. A B-tier Thieving idle that funds Herblore ingredients can be correct; an S-looking GP method that starves food production is not.
Re-rank triggers
Update your personal list when:
- A patch changes potion tiers or early GP — see Updates
- Act 2 demands a neglected skill
- You unlock a shop tool that flips a skill’s XP/hr
- Combat deaths prove Defence was underrated
Related hubs
- Tier List Hub
- Skills guide
- Combat guide
- Tools for offline planning
This list will evolve with Early Access. Favour multipliers, food, and quest readiness every time the meta feels noisy.
Sample day-two account audit
Ask:
- Is Auto Eat permanently stocked?
- Do I have at least Apprentice-level Mastery progress on two gathering skills?
- Have I touched Astrology or Herblore since unlock?
- Is Defence within shouting distance of my offensive skills?
- Did I advance an Act step this week?
If you answer no twice, ignore exotic money methods and return to S/A tier fundamentals.
Tier list versus streamer order
Streamers sometimes showcase flashy combat or pet hunts because they entertain. Your silent account grows faster on food, Mastery, and multiplier skills. Watch creatively, train boringly, then spend the saved time on Quests bosses you can actually survive.
Frequently Asked Questions
Quick answers to the most common questions.
Should I max Woodcutting before anything else?
No. Use Woodcutting to open the game, then secure Cooking, Mastery tasks, and multiplier skills.
Is combat S tier early?
Combat readiness is mandatory, but raw Attack grinding without food and Defence is a trap. Defence sits in A tier for a reason.
Where does Agility land?
A tier. It unlocks content and utility gear that boost other non-combat skills.
How often should I revisit this tier list?
After each major patch and whenever Act requirements force a new skill into your critical path.